 (c)2005 Paul
Marshall
If you're anything
like me, you will have maybe hundreds of tippers that you will have bought and
made, all in the search for the 'one'.
Steafan Hannigan
says that we never really own tippers we only just borrow them for a while as
they always seem to disappear.
It's useful
therefore to look at the types of Tipper that suit you and then to look at
variables within types. Because they are generally made of natural materials,
each tipper will have individual characteristics but there are several
guidelines which can help you weed through a pile of tippers and select those
which are most likely to suit your playing style(s) and your drum(s).
Generally tippers
selected for playing top end are taken from violin bows or made to similar
dimensions and weights. The use of violin bows as the source of tippers derives
from drum maker Seamus O'Kane. These tippers are made from
Pernambuco wood, the traditional bow material, selected for its density and its
strength. There are a number of defining characteristics.
- proportionally
thin,
- plain (i.e. non
bulbous ends)
- slight taper.
- greater or lesser
curvature in the wood.
Tipper
Length
- Pure Drop
Top or hybrid Top 'n' Kerry? -
For hybrid top end
play to include traditional Kerry style triplets, lengths vary, with 9" being
fairly standard on an O'Kane size drum. As a rule of thumb the appropriate
length of stick for you is found by measuring the span of your
hand between thumb & pinky and add 1". In my case, my hand is around an 8"
span and a 9" tipper is indicated. My own personal preference runs counter to
this and I prefer 7.5 - 8" although I will move to a 9" tipper if I am playing
pure Kerry style.
For Bottom Only
(BO) striking the tippers are shorter, thinner and lighter, lengths range from
6" to 8". The shorter, lighter stick means that by increasing the potential for
hand speed, the practised player can readily compensate for not being able to do
conventional triplets plus add many more rhythmical tools to the
arsenal.
Tipper Weight
- Efficiency
- The quest for maximum effect with minimum effort -
There is an obvious
connection between the length of a tipper and its weight. The slight taper of a
violin bow means that a disproportionate amount of the tipper's weight is above
the thumb. Violin & Cello bows provide 9" lengths with weights between 12
and 22 grammes with an average being 15 - 18g.
Compared to a
lighter stick, a heavier tipper will impart more energy into the drum's skin,
this translates as increased volume and an increase in the bass response of the
drum. However... A longer & heavier tipper will obviously require more inertia (read
effort) to move it than a lighter one; and then even more effort to
reverse direction at the top of the 'swing' in order to undertake the second
part of the stroke. This means that a lot of the players' energy is invested in
merely moving the stick - a heavy tipper will have a slower 'action' than a
lighter one.
It is common for
beginner players to use heavy sticks with large bulbous ends as this gives them
a better response from the drum however this is absolutely with greater effort
and at the expense of efficiency, it is occasionally a cause of wrist / arm pain
after a prolonged playing session.
Given that there is
a definite trade off between maximising the sound caused by the stroke and
minimising the effort required by the player it is important that you take into
account a number of factors when selecting your tippers.
Matching the
tipper to the drum
- One size
definitely does not fit all -
In my time I have
come across bodhráns ranging from 24" to 10" and with skins ranging from 2mm to
0,3mm thick, from my experience, it's clear that there is no single tipper which
is suitable for all drums.
A traditional heavy
skinned 18" drum will clearly require more energy to move the skin efficiently
than say a Lambeg-skinned 12". The knock-on effect of using a larger drum and
heavier tipper will be that the potential speed available is compromised by the
effort of hefting a larger weight.
Below I give rules
of thumb that I have found are fairly close to that which I have seen in my
discussions & travels. They are given as guideline approximations and be
aware that personal preferences plus an exceptionally thin or thick skin will
definitely be a factor, however it is a useful guideline. These figures refer to
straight tippers and to medium weight drum heads.
As a rough rule of
thumb I work on 0.6 inches of tipper per inch of drum therefore a tipper for an
18" drum will be somewhere around 10-11", a tipper for a 15" drum is about 9"
and 12" drum tipper will be around 7".
In terms of weight,
my rule of thumb is approximately a gramme per inch of drum head, an 18" drum
takes an 18g tipper, a 15" drum is a 15g tipper and a 12" drum, a 12g
tipper.
|